Arizonian vs Goodyear Tires: Which Brand To Choose?

The tire market offers many choices to meet different needs and budgets. High-end luxury and premium tires are known for their top-notch performance and grip. They are leaders in tire technology, offering unmatched handling.

Budget premium tires, however, provide a more affordable option without sacrificing much performance. Although they don’t match top-tier tires, they still offer good functionality.

Moving down, budget tires are great for daily driving but not for long distances or tough conditions. They are a good balance between cost and quality, ideal for budget shoppers.

At the bottom are affordable economy tires, like those from Arizonian. They lack in performance but are very cheap.

Now, let’s compare Arizonian and Goodyear tires. We’ll see how a low-tier brand stacks up against the industry leader. By looking at their features and performance, we’ll decide if paying more for premium tires is worth it.

PerformanceAbove averageSuperior
DurabilityAbove averageSuperior
VarietyOnly has 2 designsWide range of designs
Warranty55,000-60,000 milesUp to 80,000 miles
Arizonian vs Goodyear Tires

Arizonian Tires

Cooper Tire & Rubber Company has a long history. It started during World War I. The company is famous for its Cooper tires. But it also makes other brands. These include Mickey Thompson, Avon, Dean, Roadmaster, Starfire, and Arizonian Tires.

Arizonian Tires are affordable. They’re sold only at Discount Tire. Similarly, Goodyear’s Douglas Tires are exclusive to Walmart. Both brands are only available in the USA. They target American customers.

Arizonian Tires began in the 1960s. They’re still sold at Discount Tire. The brand focuses on safety and affordability. Despite being cheap, these tires match the quality of Chinese budget brands. They’re popular for saving money.

These tires are ideal for low-mileage drivers and owners of older cars. They work well in dry conditions. However, their performance drops in wet or snowy weather.

Goodyear History

At the start of the 20th century, Frank Seiberling founded Goodyear Tire in Ohio, named after Charles Goodyear. This was the inventor of vulcanized rubber. Since 1898, Goodyear has been a leader in the tire industry.

Before World War I, Goodyear made important advances. It introduced the first tubeless tire and made the first airplane tire in 1909. Notably, Goodyear supplied tires for the famous Ford Model T, which launched in 1908. By 1926, Goodyear became the world’s largest tire company, thanks to its focus on innovation.

In 1947, Goodyear introduced nylon tires, a game-changer. Less than twenty years later, it made its billionth tire. At the same time, Goodyear strengthened its position in motorsport, a commitment it still honors.

Today, in 2022, Goodyear excels in automotive and aviation tires. It offers a wide range of products, including motorcycle and commercial tires. It also focuses on rubber-based items. Goodyear’s dedication to innovation continues to drive tire technology forward.

Major Differences Between These Two Brands

1. Performance

Both Arizonian and Goodyear tires deliver commendable performance on the road. Goodyear offers a wider tire range, ideal for various weather and roads. It includes summer, winter, and all-terrain tires. In all-season touring, Goodyear’s Assurance line stands out. Models like WeatherReady and Maxlife earn top marks from consumers. They also perform better than Arizonian tires across dry, wet, and snow conditions. Yet, Arizonian’s Silver Edition, though not as good, still offers good grip and handling for those on a budget.

2. Durability

Goodyear tires are known for their great durability. With regular care, they last a long time. Most Goodyear tires have treadwear scores of 550 to 650. Some, like the Assurance Maxlife, score as high as 820. However, high-performance models like the F1 Supercar may have lower scores due to their advanced features.

Arizonian tires are also tough. Their treadwear scores are 600 and 540 for models like the Silver Edition All-season and Silver Edition III. While Goodyear tires generally last longer, Arizonian tires are still a good value. They are more durable than many other brands.

3. Availability

Goodyear’s wide range of tires makes it the top choice for availability. It’s a major player, offering many designs for various vehicles. In contrast, Arizonian has only two tire designs, limiting choices compared to Goodyear.

4. Pricing

Arizonian tires are notably more budget-friendly compared to Goodyear’s premium offerings. This price difference reflects the superior quality and performance of Goodyear tires. Arizonian tires typically range from $80 to $145, with common sizes like the Arizonian Silver Edition 215 65R16 priced at $105. In contrast, Goodyear tires can range from $50 to $120 more expensive, with some designs costing up to $860. Despite the price disparity, both brands offer options catering to various budget ranges.

Notable Tires of Each Brand

Arizonian Tire Family

Arizonian Tires is exclusive to Discount Tire. So, to buy them, visit the Discount Tire website. Currently, only a few Arizonian tire lines are available, with just two on offer.

Arizonian Silver Edition All Season

Arizonian Silver Edition All Season

The Arizonian Silver Edition All-Season tire is a reliable and affordable choice. It’s for those who need good performance without spending too much. It fits various vehicles, from cars to SUVs and trucks. The tire gets positive reviews for its dry performance. However, it struggles on wet roads, in snow, and on ice. Also, it might not be as quiet or comfortable as more expensive brands.

Arizonian Silver Edition III

Arizonian Silver Edition III

The Arizonian Silver Edition III is the brand’s newest tire. It’s for cars, minivans, and sedans. It offers a smooth ride, better wet performance, and longer wear than the older Silver Edition. However, it lacks good traction on snow and ice. Some users want more size options for different vehicles.

Goodyear Tire Family

We’ve noted that Goodyear is huge. It dominates the market, including niche areas. Whether it’s for a car, an airplane, a van, an RV, a motorcycle, or an off-road vehicle, Goodyear has the right tire for you. In this list, we’ll focus on tires for passenger cars, SUVs, trucks, and crossovers.

Goodyear Assurance

Goodyear Assurance

The Goodyear Assurance lineup is famous for its durability, quality, and flexibility. It offers touring tires that match performance tires in many ways. Models include Fuel Max, MaxLife, Finesse, WeatherReady, and ComfortDrive. They suit a variety of passenger cars and provide reliable performance in different conditions.

Goodyear Eagle

Goodyear Eagle

The Goodyear Eagle lineup is ideal for performance tires. It suits cars like the MX-5 Miata and supercars. These tires offer great performance and comfort. The lineup includes models like Eagle Sport, F1, and LS. Each meets specific needs, from durability to maximum grip.

Goodyear Ultra Grip

Goodyear Ultra Grip

The Goodyear Ultra Grip lineup is ideal for winter. It includes tires for snow, ice, slush, and dirt. They also offer excellent dry traction. Models like the Ultra Grip GW2/3, Ice WRT, and standard Ultra Grip are for small cars, SUVs, trucks, and off-road vehicles.

Goodyear Winter Command

Goodyear Winter Command

Goodyear also has Winter Command tires for winter conditions. Some models have studs for better ice grip. These tires are best in harsh winter areas, even though sizes are limited.

Goodyear Wrangler

Goodyear Wrangler

The Goodyear Wrangler lineup is famous for its off-road ability. It delivers excellent traction across different terrains. It offers about 20 models and variations. These include tires for extreme off-roading and mud. This variety meets the needs of off-road enthusiasts.

Goodyear Efficient Grip & Excellence

Goodyear Efficient Grip & Excellence

The Goodyear Efficient Grip and Excellence tire families are efficient and suitable for touring. They provide good performance and traction without sacrificing fuel efficiency. The Efficient Grip series has two versions. Also, both families are compatible with most passenger cars.

Goodyear Fierce

Goodyear Fierce

It is ideal for trucks and SUVs used for off-roading. They can keep using them for daily driving. The Goodyear Fierce lineup offers serious off-road abilities. But, it also surprises with comfort and quietness at highway speeds.

Goodyear Frontera

Goodyear Frontera

The tires cater to SUV and truck drivers. They prioritize comfort over off-road performance. The Goodyear Frontera lineup offers comfort-focused tires for highway driving.

Goodyear Integrity

Goodyear Integrity

The Goodyear Integrity lineup is an entry-level option. It offers affordable all-season tires for various car types. They are widely available and provide decent quality without breaking the bank.

Advantages: Arizonian Tires and Goodyear Tires

AdvantagesArizonian TiresGoodyear Tires
Cheaper✓ Lower price point
Availability✓ Widely available at Discount Tire locations across the US
Suitable for Old Cars✓ Ideal for older vehicles with low mileage
Warranty Coverage✓ Good warranty coverage for the price✓ Better warranty
Performance✓ Better performance
Options✓ More tire options
Other Advantages✓ Comprehensive range of products, industry leadership

Which Brand To Choose?

Goodyear is the top brand, no question. While Arizonian tires are helpful for some, Goodyear suits everyone. Its models are a bit pricey, but you have to pay for quality.

In our comparison, Goodyear stands out. Yet, sometimes, Arizonian tires are a smart choice.

Vehucle Arizonian Tires and Goodyear Tires Will Fit

Vehicle TypeArizonian TiresGoodyear Tires
Passenger Cars✓ Fits most passenger cars✓ Fits most passenger cars
SUVs✓ Fits SUVs✓ Fits SUVs
Trucks✓ Fits trucks✓ Fits trucks
Minivans✓ Fits minivans
Sedans✓ Fits sedans
Crossovers✓ Fits crossovers
Off-road Vehicles✓ Off-road options available (e.g., Wrangler, Fierce)


Who manufactures Arizonian Tires?

Cooper Tire & Rubber Company makes Arizonian Tires. It is one of Cooper’s brands. These tires are only sold in the United States through Discount Tire.

Where are Arizonian Tires made?

Cooper Tire makes Arizonian Tires in the U.S. They come in a few designs and are only sold here. So, they are not made abroad.


Good tires matter. Goodyear’s are top-notch. Yet, some drivers just need affordable, working tires. That’s where Arizonian steps in.

I hope this review of Arizonian Tires versus Goodyear was helpful. Share it with your family and friends to spread the word about these brands.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top